Holy Moses Cakes and Pies

WELCOME TO HOLY MOSES CAKES AND PIES!!! WINNER OF THE NO.1 CHEESECAKE IN A VARIETY OF CATEGORIES!


Cart 0
Cart 0
  • Home
  • Delicious Items
    • CHEESECAKES
      • Original Cheesecake
      • Oreo Cookie Cheesecake
      • Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
      • Chocolate Marble Cheesecake
      • Strawberry Cheesecake
      • Cherry Cheesecake
      • Gluten Free Cheesecake
      • Raspberry Cheesecake
      • Keylime Cheesecake
      • Sugar Free Cheesecake
    • SAMPLER
      • Assorted Cheesecake Sampler
      • New York 2.5 !!
    • PIE
      • Pecan Pie
      • Blueberry Pie
      • Apple Crumb Pie
  • About Us
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Shipping
  • Home
  • Delicious Items
    • CHEESECAKES
      • Original Cheesecake
      • Oreo Cookie Cheesecake
      • Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
      • Chocolate Marble Cheesecake
      • Strawberry Cheesecake
      • Cherry Cheesecake
      • Gluten Free Cheesecake
      • Raspberry Cheesecake
      • Keylime Cheesecake
      • Sugar Free Cheesecake
    • SAMPLER
      • Assorted Cheesecake Sampler
      • New York 2.5 !!
    • PIE
      • Pecan Pie
      • Blueberry Pie
      • Apple Crumb Pie
  • About Us
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Shipping


SHOP FOR

More categories ›
CHEESECAKES
CHEESECAKES
SAMPLER
SAMPLER

HOLY MOSES CHEESECAKES

More cheesecakes ›
ORIGINAL NEW YORK CHEESECAKE

ORIGINAL NEW YORK CHEESECAKE

Regular price $2900 $29.00
OREO COOKIE CHEESECAKE

OREO COOKIE CHEESECAKE

Regular price $2900 $29.00
CHOCOLATE CHIP CHEESECAKE

CHOCOLATE CHIP CHEESECAKE

Regular price $2900 $29.00
STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE

STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE

Regular price $2900 $29.00
SUGAR FREE CHEESECAKE!

SUGAR FREE CHEESECAKE!

Regular price $2900 $29.00
KEY LIME CHEESECAKE

KEY LIME CHEESECAKE

Regular price $2900 $29.00
CHERRY CHEESECAKE

CHERRY CHEESECAKE

Regular price $2900 $29.00
CHOCOLATE MARBLE CHEESECAKE

CHOCOLATE MARBLE CHEESECAKE

Regular price $2900 $29.00
RASPBERRY CHEESECAKE

RASPBERRY CHEESECAKE

Regular price $2900 $29.00
7" GLUTEN FREE CHEESECAKE

7" GLUTEN FREE CHEESECAKE

Regular price $3200 $32.00
IRISH CREME CHEESECAKE

IRISH CREME CHEESECAKE

Regular price $2900 $29.00

HOLY MOSES PIES

More pies ›
PECAN PIE

PECAN PIE

Sale price $3499 $34.99 Save $5
APPLE CRUMB PIE

APPLE CRUMB PIE

Regular price $3299 $32.99
BLUEBERRY CRUMB PIE

BLUEBERRY CRUMB PIE

Regular price $3499 $34.99

Holy Moses Cheesecakes and Pies

Thanks so much for visiting our online store. Holy Moses Cakes and Pies has been baking cheesecakes and pies for over 20 years. A parish priest from New Orleans had a housekeeper who used to win contests all over the deep south with her cheesecake recipes. When she died, she willed the recipes to the good father. His nephew brought the recipes to the east end of Long Island, NY and with some friends started baking these amazing creamy cheesecakes! Baked in tube pans these unique cheesecakes are special and have a creamy taste thats out of this world!!!  

COMPANY INFORMATION

  • Search
  • Shop Now
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

CUSTOMER SERVICE

  • FAQ/Handling
  • Shipping
  • Privacy

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

  • © 2019 Holy Moses Cakes and Pies
  • american express
  • apple pay
  • diners club
  • discover
  • google pay
  • jcb
  • master
  • shopify pay
  • visa